Building the Nest: Eagles 2024 Mock Draft

The Philadelphia Eagles entered the 2024 NFL Draft with eight picks, aiming to address needs on both sides of the ball.

With two top-60 selections, analysts projected the Eagles to bolster their offensive line or secondary. They also lacked a clear edge rusher after trading away Haason Reddick. General Manager Howie Roseman’s strategy remains to be seen, but the draft provided an opportunity to fill holes and build depth for the Eagles’ future.

Olumuyiwa Fashanu: A Perfect Match for the Eagles at Pick 23.

The Philadelphia Eagles, after a savvy trade back with the Minnesota Vikings, find themselves in a position to address a major need at offensive tackle with the 23rd pick in the 2024 NFL Draft. Enter Olumuyiwa Fashanu, the talented Penn State tackle, who could be a steal at this spot.

Fashanu’s Strengths:

Elite Pass Protection: Fashanu boasts an ideal frame (6-6, 312 lbs) with exceptional athleticism. Scouts rave about his footwork, hand placement, and ability to mirror speed rushers. He didn’t allow a single sack in his college career, a testament to his technique and dominance.
High Ceiling: While still young, Fashanu possesses the physical tools and football IQ to develop into a franchise left tackle. His impressive work ethic suggests a commitment to improvement.

Areas for Development:

Run Blocking: While Fashanu excels in pass protection, his run blocking requires refinement. He can struggle to sustain blocks against powerful defensive linemen and needs to improve his pad level.
Experience: Injuries limited Fashanu’s starting experience in college. He’ll need to adjust to the increased speed and complexity of the NFL.

Why the Eagles Take Fashanu:

Protecting Hurts: Jalen Hurts‘ development hinges on a strong offensive line. Fashanu’s pass-blocking prowess would be a boon for the Eagles’ young quarterback.
Long-Term Solution: With Lane Johnson nearing retirement, the Eagles need a long-term solution at tackle. Fashanu has the potential to be a cornerstone for years to come.
Value Pick: The tradeback allows the Eagles to address a need while acquiring additional assets. If Fashanu falls to 23, they’ll be getting a top-tier talent.

Potential Concerns:

Run Blocking Needs: The Eagles already have a weakness in run blocking. Drafting Fashanu might require further investment on the offensive line.
Better Options Available: Depending on the draft board, higher-rated run-blocking tackles could be available at 23.

Overall, drafting Olumuyiwa Fashanu at pick 23 is a calculated gamble for the Eagles. His elite pass-blocking skills perfectly complement Jalen Hurts’ development, and his high ceiling offers a long-term solution at tackle. However, the Eagles must weigh Fashanu’s potential against his run-blocking limitations and the availability of other options.

Grade: A+

Edgerrin Cooper: A Thumping Addition for the Eagles’ Defense (Pick 53)

The Philadelphia Eagles, after trading up a few spots with the Houston Texans, find themselves in a position to address their linebacker depth with the 53rd pick in the 2024 NFL Draft. Enter Edgerrin Cooper, the hard-hitting linebacker from Texas A&M, who could be a valuable addition to the Eagles’ defensive unit.

Cooper’s Strengths:

Run Defense: Cooper is known for his aggressive downhill running style. He excels at diagnosing run plays and making impactful tackles. His 84 tackles in 2023 showcase his ability to consistently shut down opposing runners.
Blitzing Ability: Cooper isn’t just a run-stuffer. He notched 10 sacks in 2023, demonstrating his prowess as a blitzer. His explosiveness and quick first step allow him to disrupt plays in the backfield.
Leadership: Described as a vocal leader on the field, Cooper has the potential to solidify communication within the Eagles’ linebacker corps.

Areas for Development:

Pass Coverage: While improving, Cooper’s coverage skills are still a work in progress. He can struggle against shifty tight ends and running backs in the passing game.
Durability: Cooper has battled minor injuries throughout his college career. The Eagles will need to ensure his physical readiness for the NFL grind.

Why the Eagles Take Cooper:

Linebacker Depth: The Eagles lack a true difference-maker at linebacker. Cooper provides immediate depth and competition at the position.
Scheme Fit: If the Eagles plan on running a more aggressive defensive scheme, Cooper’s downhill style and blitzing ability would be a perfect fit.
Value Pick: At pick 53, Cooper represents good value for a player with his talent and leadership qualities.

Potential Concerns:

Coverage Needs: Drafting Cooper might not fully address the Eagles’ need for a coverage linebacker, especially if they struggle to contain tight ends.
Higher-Rated Options: Depending on the draft board, the Eagles might find more well-rounded linebackers available at pick 53.

Overall, drafting Edgerrin Cooper could be a strategic move for the Eagles. He brings a physical presence and leadership qualities that the linebacking group lacks. However, the Eagles will need to consider his limitations in pass coverage and weigh his value against other options available at pick 53.

Grade: A+

Cam Hart: A Polished Cornerback Fits the Eagles’ Needs at Pick 59

The Philadelphia Eagles head into the later rounds of the draft with a glaring need for secondary depth, particularly at cornerback. Cam Hart, the well-rounded cornerback from Notre Dame, could be a sleeper pick for the Eagles at number 59.

Hart’s Strengths:

Versatility: Hart possesses the size (6’0″, 195 lbs) and athleticism to play both press-man and zone coverage. He can line up against bigger receivers outside and has the speed to handle slot duties.
Ball Skills: Hart boasts good instincts and awareness in coverage. He recorded 5 interceptions in 2023, showcasing his ability to track the ball and make plays on throws.
Experience: A three-year starter at Notre Dame, Hart has a wealth of experience in various defensive schemes. He’s a polished player ready to contribute immediately.

Areas for Development:

Physicality: While not a liability, Hart could add some muscle to his frame to better battle bigger receivers at the NFL level.
Tackling: While a sure tackler in open space, Hart can struggle to wrap up bigger running backs in the screen game.

Why the Eagles Take Hart:

Secondary Depth: The Eagles’ secondary lacks proven depth behind Darius Slay. Hart provides immediate competition and insurance in case of injury.
Scheme Versatility: Jonathan Gannon’s defense utilizes a variety of coverages. Hart’s ability to adapt to different schemes makes him a valuable piece.
Value Pick: In the later rounds, finding a starting-caliber cornerback like Hart would be a steal for the Eagles.

Potential Concerns:

Reaching for Need: With other positions potentially needing more immediate attention, drafting a cornerback at 59 could be seen as a reach.
Higher-Rated Players Available: Depending on the remaining draft board, the Eagles might find players with higher upside at other positions.

Overall, drafting Cam Hart at pick 59 could be a savvy move for the Eagles. He brings a blend of experience, versatility, and ball skills that their secondary craves. However, the Eagles will need to weigh the value of a cornerback versus addressing other needs and ensure they aren’t reaching due to their secondary depth concerns.

Grade: C+

Brenden Rice: A High-Risk, High-Reward Pick for the Eagles at 120

The Philadelphia Eagles, with a deep receiving corps already in place, might surprise some by selecting Brenden Rice, son of the legendary Jerry Rice, in the later rounds of the draft. Here’s a breakdown of why the Eagles might take a chance on Rice at pick 120.

Rice’s Strengths:

Explosive Playmaker: Rice possesses good speed (4.5 40-yard dash) and route-running ability. He averaged over 17 yards per catch in his breakout 2023 season at USC, showcasing his big-play potential.
Pedigree: There’s no denying the Rice name carries weight. While not a guarantee of success, Brenden has shown dedication and a strong work ethic, qualities instilled by his father.
Value Pick: At pick 120, Rice represents a potential high-reward selection. If he develops, he could become a valuable contributor at a minimal cost.

Areas for Development:

Limited Experience: Rice only has one year of significant production at USC. He’ll need to adjust to the complexities of the NFL game.
Route Running Refinement: While promising, Rice’s route tree could benefit from further development. He might struggle initially against NFL-caliber defensive backs.
Not an Immediate Need: With A.J. Brown and DeVonta Smith entrenched as the Eagles’ top receivers, Rice wouldn’t be an immediate starter.

Why the Eagles Take Rice:

Depth and Upside: The Eagles can afford to take a flier on a player with Rice’s upside. He adds depth to the receiving corps and could develop into a reliable option down the line.
Coaching Potential: The Eagles have a proven track record of developing young receivers. Their coaching staff might believe they can unlock Rice’s full potential.
Family Connection: While not the primary factor, Rice name recognition could generate positive publicity for the Eagles organization.

Potential Concerns:

Redundancy at Receiver: Drafting a receiver at 120 might be seen as unnecessary with the talent already on the roster.
Other Needs: The Eagles might have more pressing needs on defense or the offensive line that could be addressed at pick 120.
Bust Potential: There’s a chance Rice doesn’t translate his college success to the NFL, leaving the Eagles with a wasted pick.

Overall, drafting Brenden Rice at 120 is a high-risk, high-reward proposition for the Eagles. While they have a strong receiving corps, Rice’s potential and pedigree could be enticing. However, the Eagles will need to weigh the value of adding another receiver against addressing other needs and the possibility of a developmental project not panning out.

Grade: A

Caelen Carson: A Late-Round Gamble on Potential for the Eagles at Pick 161

With the draft winding down, the Philadelphia Eagles look to bolster their defensive depth with their final pick at 161. Caelen Carson, a defensive tackle from a smaller program (Wake Forrest), could be an intriguing late-round flier for the Eagles.

Carson’s Strengths:

Disruptive Interior Presence: Despite playing at South Alabama, Carson garnered recognition for his ability to disrupt plays in the trenches. He boasts a strong motor and surprising athleticism for his size (6’2″, 305 lbs).
Penetration Skills: Carson excels at getting into the backfield, collapsing the pocket, and disrupting running plays.
High-Character Player: Known for his work ethic and leadership qualities, Carson could be a positive influence in the Eagles’ locker room.

Areas for Development:

Strength Against the Run: While disruptive, Carson can struggle to anchor against bigger blockers in the running game. He’ll need to add functional strength at the NFL level.
Limited Competition: Playing against lesser competition in college raises questions about how Carson will translate to facing NFL offensive linemen.
Pass Rushing Finesse: Primarily a run-stuffer, Carson needs to develop more pass-rushing moves to become a more complete defensive lineman.

Why the Eagles Take Carson:

Depth on the Defensive Line: The Eagles’ defensive line lacks proven depth behind Fletcher Cox and Javon Hargrave. Carson provides competition and insurance in case of injury.
Developmental Potential: The Eagles have a strong defensive coaching staff with a history of developing raw talent. Carson’s motor and athleticism give him a foundation to build on.
Low-Risk, High-Reward Pick: At pick 161, there’s minimal risk in selecting Carson. If he develops, he could become a valuable rotational piece on the defensive line.

Potential Concerns:

Reaching for Need: With other positions potentially needing more immediate attention, drafting a defensive tackle this late might be considered unnecessary.
Limited Ceiling: Carson might be best suited as a rotational player and may not develop into a starter.
Unknown Quantity: The jump in competition from South Alabama to the NFL is significant, and there’s a chance Carson struggles to adapt.

Overall, drafting Caelen Carson at pick 161 is a low-risk gamble for the Eagles. His potential and work ethic are enticing, but questions remain about his ability to translate his college success to the NFL. The Eagles will need to determine if his developmental upside outweighs the need to address other depth concerns on the roster.

Grade B+

McKinnley Jackson: A Project DT with Upside for the Eagles (Pick 171)

Jackson is a defensive tackle prospect with a mix of intriguing strengths and some limitations that could affect his draft position. Here’s a breakdown:

Strengths:

Explosive First Step: Jackson gets off the snap quickly, disrupting offensive lines and penetrating gaps in the run game.
Strong and Powerful: He uses his strength and leverage to control blockers, anchor against double teams, and occupy multiple blockers.
Decent Pass Rush: While not a dominant pass rusher, he shows flashes of power and finesse moves to get to the quarterback.

Weaknesses:

Size: At 6’1″ and 326 lbs, he might be considered undersized for a traditional nose tackle in the NFL.
Limited Arm Length: His shorter arms could be a disadvantage against taller offensive linemen.
Inconsistent Technique: He struggles at times with hand placement and maintaining a wide base, leading to issues shedding blocks.
Pass Rushing Repertoire: Relies heavily on his initial burst and needs to develop a broader pass rush arsenal.

Overall:

Jackson is a fringe top-100 prospect with the potential to be a solid contributor. Teams seeking a run-stuffing defensive tackle with upside as a pass rusher might target him in the mid-to-late rounds (Day 2) or as a value pick on Day 3.

Grade A+

Sione Vaki: A Late-Round Steal for the Eagles’ Secondary (Pick 172)

Philadelphia Eagles have a chance to add depth and competition to their secondary by selecting Sione Vaki, a safety from the University of Utah. Here’s a breakdown of why Vaki could be a valuable late-round addition for the Eagles.

Vaki’s Strengths:

High Football IQ: Vaki is known for his instincts and ability to diagnose p ok lays quickly. He excels in zone coverage and excels at reacting to offensive adjustments.
Run Support: Vaki is a willing run defender who comes downhill with good tackling technique. He can contribute to setting the edge and preventing big gains on the ground.
Special Teams Contributor: Vaki has experience on various special teams units in college, adding immediate value to coverage and return teams.

Areas for Development:

Limited Coverage Range: While strong in zone coverage, Vaki might struggle to keep up with speedy tight ends or slot receivers in man coverage.
Lack of Elite Measurables: Vaki doesn’t possess elite speed or athleticism, which could limit his effectiveness against high-powered passing offenses.
Depth Player Projection: Vaki is likely best suited as a rotational safety and special teams contributor early in his career.

Why the Eagles Take Vaki:

Secondary Depth: The Eagles lack proven depth behind starters Marcus Epps and Rodney McLeod. Vaki provides immediate competition and insurance against injury.
Scheme Fit: Jonathan Gannon’s defense relies heavily on zone coverage and strong run support, areas where Vaki excels.
Late-Round Value: At pick 172, Vaki represents a minimal risk with the potential for a solid special teams contributor and a rotational safety option.

Potential Concerns:

Redundancy at Safety: If the Eagles are comfortable with their current safety depth, drafting another safety this late might be considered unnecessary.
Need at Other Positions: The Eagles might have more pressing needs on their offensive line or at linebacker that could be addressed with pick 172.
Limited Upside: Vaki’s skillset might limit him to a backup role, offering minimal long-term impact.

Overall, drafting Sione Vaki at pick 172 is a low-risk move for the Eagles. His football IQ and tackling prowess fit well within their defensive scheme. However, the Eagles will need to weigh the value of adding another safety against addressing other needs and ensure they aren’t neglecting positions with a higher potential impact.

Grade A+

A.J. Barner: A Developmental Tight End for the Eagles’ Future at Pick 210

The Philadelphia Eagles enter the later rounds of the draft with a focus on finding future contributors. Tight-end A.J. Barner from Michigan might be a project player with intriguing upside at pick 210.

Barner’s Strengths:

Elite Size and Frame: At 6’6″ and 251 lbs, Barner possesses the ideal build for an NFL tight end. His size makes him a mismatch in the red zone and a reliable target for contested catches.
Solid Run Blocking: Barner excels as a run blocker. He uses his size and technique to seal off defenders and create running lanes. This could be valuable for the Eagles’ run-heavy offense.
Unexploited Potential: Primarily used as a blocker at Michigan, Barner hasn’t fully developed his receiving skills. This lack of polish could translate to a lower draft pick, presenting a potential steal for the Eagles.

Areas for Development:

Limited Route Running: Barner’s route-running repertoire is underdeveloped. He struggles with sharp breaks and creating separation against tight coverage.
Needs Refinement as a Pass Catcher: While he has good hands and leaping ability, Barner needs work on catching in traffic and becoming a more well-rounded receiving threat.
Long-Term Development Project: Barner might not be a day-one contributor and will require significant coaching and development to reach his full potential.

Why the Eagles Take Barner:

Long-Term Investment: Dallas Goedert is a solid starter, but the Eagles lack a reliable backup tight end. Barner has the potential to develop into Goedert’s successor.
Coaching Up Potential: The Eagles have a history of developing young tight ends. They might believe they can refine Barner’s receiving skills and unlock his potential.
Value Pick: In the 7th round, drafting Barner is a low-risk, high-reward proposition. If he develops, he could become a valuable contributor at tight end.

Potential Concerns:

Immediate Need vs. Future Investment: With other positions potentially needing more immediate attention, drafting a developmental tight end this late might be a luxury.
Limited Offensive Upside: Even with development, Barner might be best suited as a blocking tight end with limited receiving impact.
Roster Spot Competition: Earning a roster spot as a rookie tight end on the Eagles will be difficult. Barner will need to show significant improvement in training camp.

Overall, drafting A.J. Barner at pick 210 is a gamble on the upside for the Eagles. His size, blocking ability, and potential as a receiver make him an intriguing project. However, the Eagles will need to weigh the long-term investment in Barner’s development against addressing more pressing needs on the roster.

Grade: A+

This mock draft was done using NFLMockDraftDatabase.com.

Use code PHILLYSPORTSREPORT for $20 off your first SeatGeek order

Click here to save 10% on any order at FOCO