Phillies Offense Pulls Final Disappearing Act of 2026

It felt fitting that Otto Kemp was the last batter of the Phillies season against Chris Sale. In a season where the team was the most inconsistent that we have seen with this core, in the final game of the season, the minute amount of magic this core still possessed finally wore off.

The overworked starting staff dug a deep hole in the first inning, and the Phillies’ offense couldn’t recover.

The Phillies had trouble scoring runs consistently all season, and they were either feast or famine. Every other month it felt like a different Phillies offense came to the park. April cost Rob Thomson his job; in May Don Mattingly was circling the wagons; in June the Phillies looked unbeatable, finding ways to win; in July they struggled mightily; in August they caught fire and were threatening the Atlanta Braves with one of the best offenses in baseball; and in September they played their worst baseball of the season, and this was a pure indictment of the Phillies offense. They made the playoffs on the last day of the regular season.

In the Wild Card round, the offense was underwhelming but nearly did enough to win in Game 1, but lost on a heartbreaking Austin Riley home run. In Game 2, they fought back from a deficit to force extra innings and take the win, and in the elimination game, the Phillies offense was all but nullified.

One thing that has been a constant all season is that when the Phillies offense flatlines, they are playing hero ball; everyone is trying to lock in on one pitch and hit it into the stratosphere. The irony is that when the offense is playing at its peak is when they are working the count and getting more than four pitches per at-bat.

“Scoring is tough, in general, with pitching the way it is,” Mattingly said after the Phillies’ 6-2 loss on Thursday, ending their season.

In a season where both Bryce Harper and Kyle Schwarber performed well, and each carried the offense for the team at different times of the season, it’s time we started looking at another player who never seemed to get on track and seemed lost at the plate all season: Trea Turner.

Turner never turned it around after a slow start, and even though he was injured early on, you’d expect that the batting champion from the prior year would not lose 60 points off his batting average.

“I think this year is the biggest question mark for me offensively in a long time,” Turner said. “I’ve got a lot of work to do. “

Turner has not been clutch in the playoffs since putting on a Phillies uniform. He is 8-for-43 over the last three postseasons, a .186 AVG with one extra-base hit and four RBI. Turner was signed to be a difference-maker and get the Phillies over the hump; instead, he has disappeared when the Phillies offense needs him most.

Symbolic of the type of season the Phillies offense had, they were 0-for-6 with RISP on Thursday. They had chances all season, but just had trouble cashing in.

Part of the issue going into this series was the injury to their mid-season pickup, Luis Arraez hurting himself in the playoff push and was not available for the Wild Card round. He offered stability in the middle of the lineup, and he was one player who didn’t surrender at-bats, which happened far too often in this series.

The biggest question marks lay ahead for the Phillies. With Arreaz and Alec Bohm being free agents, the Phillies offense could look much different next season. Removing either of them from the lineup doesn’t make the team better at all, but the business of baseball is a rough one, and tough decisions will have to be made after a third straight early playoff collapse.

“I’d imagine this team is going to look a lot different next year,” Harper said, “with the guys that are kind of leaving this clubhouse.”

The Phillies only managed one day of October this season, and it was a heartbreaking one. With so many questions this offseason, it’s natural to wonder what the Phillies will do to get better offensively for 2027, but there doesn’t seem to be an easy path.

The team needs a bit of a reset, and it looks like that will reportedly be Mattingly, as he is not expected to return as the Phillies’ manager in 2027, according to Bob Nightengale of USA Today. But others who are integral to the offense and the preparation of the hitters may also be in need of a hard reboot, namely hitting coach Kevin Long. While he is well liked in the organization, the offense and hitting under him have been far too inconsistent to ignore any longer. Perhaps the next manager can bring in someone they work well with to be the hitting coach.

Get New Articles Emailed Right To Your Inbox: