Phillies Pushing Nick Castellanos Distraction Into The Past Following His Release

The Nick Castellanos Era in Philadelphia is over, and the Phillies are officially moving on.

It’s been three days now since outfielder Castellanos was released by the Philadelphia Phillies, ending his time with the Phils at four seasons. Castellanos had one year remaining on the five-year deal that he signed back in 2022.

Releasing Castellanos was an expected move, as four months ago, Phillies president of baseball operations, Dave Dombrowski, told the media that the team was either going to trade Castellanos if they found a suitor that would pay some of his $20 million owed, or if they couldn’t, he’d be released. Shockingly, nobody balked at trading for Castellanos, and with the Phillies getting ramped up for spring training, they finally bit the bullet and released Castellanos.

The change of scenery for Castellanos could be for several reasons, but the main one is the incident that occurred back in June in Miami during a matchup with the Marlins. During the game, Castellanos was taken out as a pinch runner. Castellanos was displeased to be taken out of the game, and because of it, went into the dugout, grabbed a beer, and was going to drink it before he was stopped by coaches.

After the game, Castellanos had a discussion with Dombrowski and Phillies manager Rob Thomson, and they decided to bench Castellanos for a game. Following that game, Castellanoss role with the Phillies became smaller and smaller, eventually getting to a platoon role with fellow outfielder Max Kepler. Castellanos wasn’t doing himself any favors, as his numbers last year were some of the worst in the league.

While it didn’t take a genius to figure it out, for whatever reason, Dombrowski decided to let the entire league know that the Phillies would be fine with releasing Castellanos if they couldn’t find trade partners. The odds of trading Castellanos were already low, but telling the world that we’re fine with just cutting him.

Obviously, teams were interested in Castellanos because less than 48 hours after he was released, the San Diego Padres agreed to a one-year league minimum deal with the outfielder. The signing will save the Phillies $1.638 million, $780,000 from the league minimum salary, and $858,000 in luxury tax penalties.

READ MORE:

The writing was on the wall for Nick Castellanos — and it came full circle

So now that the deed is done, where does that leave the Phillies? Their next step is simple: move on and leave the issues in the past.

I’m not gonna sit here and say that Castellanos’ outburst with Thomson was the reason the Phillies didn’t win the World Series last season, but you can’t deny that it didn’t help. It was a distraction towards the rest of the team, that Castellanos could say what he said to Thomson, and was still getting playing time.

When asked if it was a distraction last season, Phillies designated hitter Kyle Schwarber essentially skated around the question and blamed the whole team for last season’s failures.

“I mean, it’s [neither] here nor there,” he said on Friday. “I mean, we did what we did, right? I felt like, in the [NLDS], we played good games, right? There were just things that we didn’t execute. We didn’t walk away with wins at the end of the day. It’s hard to say here nor there. We put ourselves in the position where we wanted to be. We just got knocked out. Can’t really say.”

For Schwarber, one of the most honest and outspoken players and essentially the captain of the Phillies, not to be honest, says a lot. It tells you that yes, Castellanos was a huge problem for this team, and now that he’s gone, they can finally be a team that has better chemistry and can have fun again.

Matt Gelb of The Athletic posted a story about the entire incident with Castellanos and what led to downfall with the Phillies. In the story, it also mentioned how Castellanos went into free agency back in 2022, just wanting the most money possible from a team that could win it all.

This just tells you that no matter what Castellanos said about wanting to be a Phillie, it wasn’t true. He wanted the most money possible, and to have a chance to win, he didn’t care where that was. The passion just wasn’t there for Castellanos, and this team is filled with guys who have the passion to bring a championship to the city of Philadelphia.

Things didn’t work out, and now the sides are separated. When talking about the decision to release Castellanos, Dombrowski spoke about where things went wrong and that Philadelphia is not the destination for Castellanos to continue playing.

“I think you just sometimes are in a situation when you’re around day in and day out, and things just don’t work at a particular time,” Dombrowski said. “A lot of the times when a good player has their role change with the club, it can cause some friction. His role changed last year; he played every single day for a lot of years in a row, and sometimes that can contribute to it. Sometimes, you just need to make sure that you have a change of scenery.”

Castellanos and the Phillies are on two different paths, as the Phillies need guys who can improve this roster and help them reach their championship aspirations, and Castellanos wants to play every day. With the signing of free agent Adolis Garcia and the likely promotion of top outfield prospect Justin Crawford, the Phillies are taking the necessary steps to move on from Castellanos

It’s now on the Phillies to pick up the pieces of the messy divorce and move into the future, and more specifically, focus on the end goal of 2026, winning a World Series.

Get New Articles Emailed Right To Your Inbox: