The Heart of the Phillies Stays Beating: Kyle Schwarber Is Back
PHILADELPHIA, PENNSYLVANIA - AUGUST 28: Kyle Schwarber #12 of the Philadelphia Phillies smiles during his post game interview after a 19-4 win over the Atlanta Braves at Citizens Bank Park on August 28, 2025 in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. Kyle Schwarber hit four home runs during the game. (Photo by Emilee Chinn/Getty Images)
We can all exhale a little. Reports from Orlando are flooding in that Kyle Schwarber is going to be signing a 5-year, $150 million contract, returning to the Phillies. While this is a fairly big payday for a 33-year-old designated hitter, this is still a pretty big hometown discount for someone who was certainly coveted by many other teams. But in the end, he feels the brotherly love, and is coming home to finish what this core started.
I know that many people felt the same as I did; I was afraid he was gone. When you let a lefty power bat that led the league in home runs and RBI explore the open market, the chances of him returning are not always going to be great. Especially when his hometown team, with a bandbox stadium, the Cincinnati Reds, gets involved. My feeling was that Schwarber wanted to see what other options there were, and he has every right to do so. We can’t say he didn’t leave everything on the field for the Phils this season because he did, and has been monetarily rewarded for it.
The fact of the matter is, even if you think this is an overpay, which I assure you it’s not, the Phillies did everything in their power to keep Schwarber on the roster for the foreseeable future. According to John Clark, the Phillies had to guarantee the 5th year instead of it being an option year, and they had to increase the AAV to $30 million to get the deal done and beat out other clubs. This tells you how much other clubs wanted him, but the Phillies just wanted him more.
Why wouldn’t they? His bat only tells part of the story of just how valuable he is to the organization. He’s undoubtedly one of the vocal clubhouse leaders, a calming force in the dugout and clubhouse, a fan favorite, the hero of the all-star game this last season, finished a close second for MVP to the guy MLB seems to have penciled in for the next 11 MVP awards, and is incredibly active in the community. Replacing all of that would have been nearly impossible, and looking at what Clark said, the front office fully agrees.
As the winter went on, and the reports were that other teams starved for a power bat were talking to Kyle and his people, I started to get nervous that he wouldn’t be back. That was always followed by a feeling of loss. The idea that the feeling of anticipation and excitement when Dan Baker announced Kyle Schwarber to the plate was over was a terrible feeling. All of the potential Phillies free agents don’t give that same reason to stop what you’re doing and intently watch their at-bats. Losing any of them will hurt, but losing Schwarber would have been a critical hit to the Phils’ chances this next season of winning the NL East yet again, and as resigned as some of us were that he was as good as gone, this has to feel like a holiday present to us all.
No other player who came in from the outside has embraced Philly as much as the clubhouse leaders now. Bryce Harper embraced the Phillies from day one, and his relationship with the Phanatic proved that Philly is where he belonged. Trea Turner didn’t get off to the best start, but he won over the fans with his perseverance. Zack Wheeler just dominated, and when you torch the Mets, you’re a made man. Schwarber is one of those guys. The way he has embraced the city as a whole, and especially the youth of Philadelphia that can’t be replaced easily.
Sure, there are other options available, Pete Alonso is out there, but since he’s a Scott Boras guy, he will be a mercenary wherever he goes with the opt-outs, Munetaka Murakami is a pretty solid gamble from Japan, Kyle Tucker is available, etc. But at the end of the day, none of them outside of Alonso have that pop that Schwarber brings. Not to mention that bringing in Alonso will likely force Harper back to the outfield, and that is a downgrade at first, since Harper has become an excellent defensive first baseman. Other options exist, but you would likely need to bring in one of these guys and another mid-tier player to equal Schwarber’s output.
This was the only move. Bringing back Schwarber shows not just to the fanbase that the front office wants to win, but it also shows the clubhouse that they want their leaders to stay. Both knowing that the Phillies have their backs is a huge testament to what they think of this team. I know we were all preparing for life after the Schwarbarian, but I’m very happy that we don’t have to live in that alternate timeline.
Steve Hamilton
Steve may have been born in California, but don’t let that fool you. After dating a local woman and clashing with her and her family over sports for decades, he has an affinity for Philly sports. Balancing love for Philly and Bay Area sports teams may seem impossible, we can all agree that the Cowboys are the true evil.
Get New Articles Emailed Right To Your Inbox:
