Why a Flashy Trade Won’t Fix What’s Actually Broken With the 76ers

There’s a consistent yearly theme surrounding the Philadelphia 76ers at the trade deadline, built on the assumption that this roster is one bold move away from changing its fate. Every rumor attached to them right now looks like a panic move rather than a personnel move to make the team better.

Start with the most audacious one, Giannis Antetokounmpo. It’s the easiest to dismiss once you strip away the name value. Any real conversation with Milwaukee begins with premium assets, which, without a doubt, means VJ Edgecombe and multiple unprotected firsts. This is the kind of move that reshapes two franchises for the next decade. The Sixers have been clear internally that Edgecombe is not a trade chip, and even if that stance softened, you’re talking about mortgaging the future for a superstar who is still elite when healthy, but is also on the back side of his career and carries massive durability questions that matter more when your own franchise center fits that same profile.

The Lauri Markkanen idea is more of a realistic idea, but it runs into the same wall once you look at Utah’s incentives. Danny Ainge rarely trades core pieces without getting back an overpay, and for the 76ers, that would show up in the form of draft capital they can’t easily replace and young talent they need to stay as deep as it was. Markkanen would help offensively, but the cost thins out the roster and would not improve the team defensively, making them less adaptable overall.

Deni Avdija is the archetype that the Sixers, as well as other teams, covet: a big wing who defends, passes, and possessions don’t end with him. But that exact profile is why Portland is going to demand a serious return for him, especially with the number of teams that seem to be in on Avdija. Two-way wings with size who can defend are currency in this league, not trade deadline afterthoughts, and acquiring one would likely require draft capital that far outweighs the upgrade he provides to the 76ers, whose problems are structural rather than positional.

Bobby Portis pops up because he’s tangible and familiar, but adding another front-court piece with money attached doesn’t address why the Sixers keep losing control of games out of halftime. Portis helps with physicality and rebounding, but he doesn’t simplify the defensive reads or clean up the offensive flow that breaks down in the third quarter, and committing future flexibility for that kind of upgrade, which feels like solving the wrong problem with the wrong kind of solution.

The smaller rumors are more realistic, and that’s also why they shouldn’t be oversold. Keon Ellis makes sense as a depth defender, not as a cure. A De’Anthony Melton reunion sounds good emotionally, but it requires perfect timing, matching salaries, and the Golden State Warriors selling, which doesn’t appear to be the case, even if the Warriors seem to be attached to every rumor the Sixers are. Saddiq Bey is mostly a financial conversation masquerading as a basketball one, useful only if paired with other moves that prioritize tax math over on-court change, but the Los Angeles Lakers are in on him as well, as they appear to be in salary-saving mode.

What ties all of these rumored moves together is the assumption that the Sixers’ season hinges on acquiring another name, when the evidence keeps pointing elsewhere. Their recurring third-quarter issues are about structure, about how the lineup functions once opponents adjust, change their plans at halftime, and defensive rotations stay the same even though the opponent has changed up matchups. None of the rumored blockbusters guarantees improvement there; in fact, several actively make it harder to address currently, as well as later, by draining future assets.

The responsible deadline move, if there is one, is boring by design and doesn’t make a splash. It’s about reducing stress and friction, not chasing upside. It’s about lineups that can survive the first punch after halftime without unraveling, not about looking good to the fanbase.

If the Sixers don’t make a major move, that won’t be a failure of nerve. It will be an acknowledgment that this season will be decided by adjustments you can’t trade for, and that sacrificing the future via draft picks, and in a worst-case scenario, losing Edgecombe just to feel different in February, is how you end up learning the same lesson in May, only with fewer options left.

No trade can fix the glaring issue with the 76ers, which has to be addressed with coaching and a tightening up of execution in the third quarter. Not to mention, the Sixers are on a current four game winning streak and playing some of the best basketball since their collapse in Charlotte last week. So here’s the real question: is this hot streak masking issues that can be fixed by new blood, or have the Sixers actually turned a corner? This is the question that will be front and center for the next couple of days until the trade deadline passes.

Get New Articles Emailed Right To Your Inbox: